When selecting among countertop ice makers, the primary tradeoff lies between ice texture preference and production speed. The GE Profile Opal Ultra stands out as the best overall choice for its ability to produce soft, chewable nugget ice that rivals commercial machines, while the Silonn SLIM21 offers the best space-saving design for cramped kitchens. Most models in this category struggle with noise levels and require frequent water refills, creating a gap between convenience and performance. Readers should prioritize ice type first, as nugget machines behave differently than traditional cube makers. Continue reading to see which model fits your specific household needs and counter space limitations.
Get kitchen gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Nugget ice makers generally require more maintenance and produce more noise than standard cube makers due to their complex compression mechanisms.
- The GE Profile Opal Ultra and SenCre models dominate the premium segment by offering side tanks that extend production time without manual refilling.
- Budget-friendly options like the Crzoe and Antarctic Star often sacrifice ice clarity and speed, producing hollow cubes that melt faster in drinks.
- Portability features such as handles and compact footprints are critical for renters or those with limited permanent counter space, highlighting the Silonn SLIM21 as a leader.
- Self-cleaning cycles are present in most mid-range models but vary in effectiveness; models with removable parts remain easier to deep clean manually.
| EUHOMY Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 35 lb Daily Capacity |  | Best Overall Nugget Ice Maker | Daily ice production: Up to 35 lb | First batch time: About 5–7 minutes | Ice basket capacity: 1.8 lb | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| EUHOMY Countertop Nugget Ice Maker with Handle |  | Best for Portability | Ice production time: As little as 6 minutes | Daily ice production: Up to 34 lb | Water tank capacity: 1.2 qt | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Crzoe Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb/Day, Two Ice Sizes, Self-Cleaning, Black |  | Best for Two Cube Sizes | Daily ice production: 26 lb | Ice shape: Bullet | Ice sizes: Small and large | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Electactic Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 35 lbs per Day |  | Best Metal-Exterior Pick | Daily ice production: 35 lb | First batch time: About 7 minutes | Water tank capacity: 1.1 L | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Crzoe Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb/Day, Two Ice Sizes, Self-Cleaning, Grey |  | Best Compact Portable Pick | Daily ice production: 26 lb | Ice production time: 8 cubes in 6–12 minutes | Ice capacity: 1.3 lb | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Antarctic Star Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb/Day |  | Best for Quiet, Compact Counters | Model: HZB-12Q | Daily ice production: 26 lb | Ice shape and sizes: Bullet; 2 sizes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Silonn SLIM21 Countertop Portable Ice Maker |  | Best for Portable Batch Making | Model: SLIM21B | Daily ice production: Up to 26 lb | First ice: About 6 minutes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire Countertop Portable Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Black Stainless Steel |  | Best for Simple Controls and Draining | Model: EFIC120-BLKSS-SC | Daily ice production: 26 lb | Ice production cycle: 9 cubes every 7 minutes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SenCre Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 60 lb/24h |  | Best for High-Output Nugget Ice | Model: NIM600S | Daily ice production: Up to 60 lb | First ice: As little as 5 minutes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker with Handle, Self-Cleaning, Black |  | Best for First-Time Ice Maker Owners | Model: IM001-B | Daily ice production: Up to 26 lb | Batch size and time: 9 cubes in about 6 minutes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Antarctic Star Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb Daily Capacity |  | Best for Quiet Operation | Daily Capacity: 26 lbs | Ice Type: Bullet | Cycle Time: 6 minutes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| EUHOMY Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 44 lb/Day, Black |  | Best High-Capacity Nugget Maker | Daily Capacity: 44 lbs | Ice Type: Nugget | Cycle Time: 7–10 minutes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| GE Profile Opal Ultra Countertop Nugget Ice Maker with 1-Gallon Side Tank |  | Best Premium Smart Feature | Daily Capacity: 38 lbs | Ice Type: Nugget | First Batch: ~10 minutes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker, 9 Cubes in 6 Minutes, 26 lb/Day, Self-Cleaning |  | Best Balanced Portable Option | Daily Capacity: 26 lbs | Ice Type: Bullet | Cycle Time: 6 minutes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire EFIC117-SS Portable Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day |  | Best for Ease of Maintenance | Daily Capacity: 26 lbs | Ice Type: Bullet | Cycle Time: 7 minutes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| countertop ice maker | Dimensions | Daily ice production | Noise level |
|---|---|---|---|
| EUHOMY Countertop Nugget Ice M | 12.28 × 11.14 × 8.5 in (H × D × W) | Up to 35 lb | Under 45 dB |
| EUHOMY Countertop Nugget Ice M | 11.61 × 9.45 × 12.99 in | Up to 34 lb | Under 45 dB |
| Crzoe Countertop Ice Maker | 10.39 × 8.66 × 11.22 in (D × W × H) | 26 lb | Less than 40 dB |
| Electactic Countertop Nugget I | 11.02 × 8.27 × 12.2 in (D × W × H) | 35 lb | Approximately 43 dB |
| Crzoe Countertop Ice Maker | 10.39 × 8.66 × 11.22 in | 26 lb | Less than 40 dB |
| Antarctic Star Countertop Ice | 10.39 × 8.66 × 11.22 in (D × W × H) | 26 lb | Below 40 dB |
| Silonn SLIM21 Countertop Porta | 11.57 × 11.42 × 8.74 in | Up to 26 lb | — |
| Frigidaire Countertop Portable | 15 × 11 × 14.5 in (D × W × H) | 26 lb | — |
| SenCre Countertop Nugget Ice M | — | Up to 60 lb | 40 dB |
| EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker wi | 11.57 × 11.42 × 8.74 in | Up to 26 lb | — |
| Antarctic Star Countertop Ice | 10.39 x 8.66 x 11.22 in | — | < 40 dB |
| EUHOMY Countertop Nugget Ice M | 13.9 x 9.85 x 14.95 in | — | — |
| GE Profile Opal Ultra Countert | — | — | — |
| EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker | 11.74 x 9.46 x 11.19 in | — | 45 dB |
| Frigidaire EFIC117-SS Portable | 9 x 13 x 13 in | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
EUHOMY Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 35 lb Daily Capacity
The EUHOMY IM039 is a strong fit for households that want chewable nugget ice without giving up much counter space. Its first batch takes about 5–7 minutes, and its stated daily output edges out the 34-pound EUHOMY model with a handle. The tradeoff is modest storage: the 1.8-pound basket can fill quickly when several people are serving drinks. A 15-minute dual-pump cleaning cycle and included cleaner packs make routine care more approachable, though the instructions call for discarding the first one or two batches after descaling. At under 45 dB, it is designed for everyday kitchen use, but it does not have the built-in carrying handle of its sibling. I’d choose this model for its blend of output, compact dimensions, and cleaning features.
Pros:- Makes chewable nugget ice in about 5–7 minutes
- Up to 35 pounds of stated daily production
- Dual-pump cleaning cycle and four included cleaner packs
- Compact footprint with a removable basket
Cons:- The 1.8-pound basket needs frequent emptying during heavy use
- Descaling requires discarding the first 1–2 batches
- No built-in handle for moving it between locations
Best for: Households that want quick, chewable nugget ice for daily drinks and have room to empty a small basket regularly
Not ideal for: People who need large stored batches for gatherings or want a handle for carrying the machine
- Daily ice production:Up to 35 lb
- First batch time:About 5–7 minutes
- Ice basket capacity:1.8 lb
- Water reservoir capacity:1.1 L
- Noise level:Under 45 dB
- Dimensions:12.28 × 11.14 × 8.5 in (H × D × W)
- Cleaning cycle:15 minutes
- Certification:ETL
Our verdict“Choose the EUHOMY IM039 for a compact daily nugget-ice supply if its small basket suits your serving pace.”
EUHOMY Countertop Nugget Ice Maker with Handle
For buyers who may move an ice maker between a kitchen, office, or RV, the built-in handle gives this EUHOMY a clearer purpose than the handle-free IM039. It makes chewable nugget ice in as little as six minutes and lists 34 pounds per day, just below that model’s 35-pound figure. The similar 1.8-pound basket means neither is suited to holding a large reserve, and this one’s 1.2-quart tank still needs periodic refilling. Water and full-basket alerts help prevent interruptions from going unnoticed, while one-touch cleaning keeps the controls simple. Its plastic construction and portable design favor convenience over a more substantial exterior. I’d pick it when moving the machine matters more than a small difference in stated output.
Pros:- Built-in handle makes it easier to carry
- Produces chewable nugget ice in as little as six minutes
- Water and full-basket alerts help track operation
- One-touch self-cleaning cycle
Cons:- The 1.8-pound basket provides limited storage
- The 1.2-quart water tank requires refilling
- Plastic construction may feel less substantial than metal-exterior alternatives
Best for: RV owners, office teams, and households that want to move a nugget ice maker between serving areas
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a large ice reserve or prefer a heavier, more substantial exterior
- Ice production time:As little as 6 minutes
- Daily ice production:Up to 34 lb
- Water tank capacity:1.2 qt
- Ice basket capacity:1.8 lb
- Wattage:144 W
- Noise level:Under 45 dB
- Dimensions:11.61 × 9.45 × 12.99 in
- Certification:ETL
Our verdict“Choose this EUHOMY if portability and simple alerts matter more to you than the IM039’s slightly higher stated daily output.”
Crzoe Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb/Day, Two Ice Sizes, Self-Cleaning, Black
The black Crzoe suits buyers who want ordinary bullet-shaped cubes and a choice of small or large pieces rather than chewable nugget ice. Its two size settings offer more control over how quickly ice chills a drink, while the EUHOMY nugget models are aimed at a softer texture. The stated output is 26 pounds per day, lower than those EUHOMY machines, and each batch of eight cubes takes about 6–12 minutes. A transparent lid lets you check progress, and the low-water and full-basket lights make its basic operation easier to follow. The compressor’s under-40-dB rating is a useful fit for shared rooms, but the water needs manual refilling. This is the more straightforward pick for buyers who prioritize cube size choice over nugget ice or higher output.
Pros:- Offers small and large bullet-cube options
- Transparent lid makes the ice-making process visible
- Low-water and full-basket indicator lights
- Self-cleaning mode and under-40-dB stated noise level
Cons:- Produces less ice per day than the EUHOMY nugget models
- Makes eight cubes per batch in about 6–12 minutes
- Requires manual water refills
Best for: Small households that prefer bullet ice and want separate small and large cube settings
Not ideal for: Nugget-ice fans or people who need higher daily production for frequent group serving
- Daily ice production:26 lb
- Ice shape:Bullet
- Ice sizes:Small and large
- Batch time:8 cubes in 6–12 minutes
- Wattage:112 W
- Noise level:Less than 40 dB
- Dimensions:10.39 × 8.66 × 11.22 in (D × W × H)
- Refrigerant:R600a
Our verdict“Choose the black Crzoe if two bullet-cube sizes matter more than nugget texture or higher daily output.”
Electactic Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 35 lbs per Day
The Electactic offers the same soft, chewable ice style and 35-pound daily output as the EUHOMY IM039, with a 430 stainless-steel exterior that may better suit a kitchen where the appliance stays on display. Its first batch takes about seven minutes, and its approximate 43-dB noise level is rated below the EUHOMY models’ under-45-dB figure. The main capacity compromise is the 1.3-pound basket, smaller than the EUHOMY machines’ 1.8-pound baskets; expect to transfer ice more often during busy use. One-touch cleaning and removable parts help with routine care, but the 1.1-liter tank still needs replenishing. I’d favor this over the EUHOMY options when the metal exterior and a slightly lower listed noise level matter more than basket size.
Pros:- Produces soft, chewable nugget ice
- Up to 35 pounds of stated daily production
- 430 stainless-steel exterior
- One-touch cleaning with removable parts
Cons:- The 1.3-pound basket is smaller than the EUHOMY models’ baskets
- The 1.1-liter water tank needs replenishment
- First batch takes about seven minutes
Best for: Buyers who want a metal-exterior nugget ice maker for a visible kitchen counter
Not ideal for: Frequent hosts who want more ice waiting in the basket between servings
- Daily ice production:35 lb
- First batch time:About 7 minutes
- Water tank capacity:1.1 L
- Ice basket capacity:1.3 lb
- Noise level:Approximately 43 dB
- Dimensions:11.02 × 8.27 × 12.2 in (D × W × H)
- Voltage:115 V
- Exterior material:430 stainless steel
Our verdict“Choose the Electactic for its metal exterior and nugget ice if you can work with a smaller basket than the EUHOMY IM039 offers.”
Crzoe Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb/Day, Two Ice Sizes, Self-Cleaning, Grey
This grey Crzoe is a small-footprint choice for buyers who want a portable bullet ice maker with two cube sizes. Its stated dimensions match the black Crzoe, but this version adds a handle and lists a 1.3-pound ice capacity, making it easier to move and serve from than a fixed-position design. The tradeoff is the same modest 26-pound daily output and 6–12-minute batches of eight cubes, well below the EUHOMY nugget machines’ stated daily production. It also produces traditional bullet ice rather than chewable nuggets, so the style of ice is a key distinction. Self-cleaning reduces some upkeep, but it does not remove the need to refill the 1.2-liter tank. I’d choose this over the black Crzoe when portability is the deciding feature.
Pros:- Built-in handle supports portability
- Small and large bullet-cube settings
- Compact dimensions and 11.77-pound listed weight
- Self-cleaning mode with included basket and scoop
Cons:- The 1.3-pound ice capacity limits stored supply
- Makes eight cubes per batch in 6–12 minutes
- Manual refilling is needed for the 1.2-liter water capacity
Best for: Apartment dwellers and occasional hosts who need a compact ice maker they can carry and store
Not ideal for: People who want chewable nugget ice or need a large supply for frequent gatherings
- Daily ice production:26 lb
- Ice production time:8 cubes in 6–12 minutes
- Ice capacity:1.3 lb
- Water capacity:1.2 L
- Ice sizes:2
- Noise level:Less than 40 dB
- Dimensions:10.39 × 8.66 × 11.22 in
- Weight:11.77 lb
Our verdict“Choose the grey Crzoe over the black version if you want a compact two-size bullet ice maker with a carrying handle.”
Antarctic Star Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb/Day
The Antarctic Star HZB-12Q is a good fit when counter space and noise matter more than a large ice reserve. At 10.39 × 8.66 inches across and below 40 dB, it has a smaller footprint and a quieter stated operating level than the Frigidaire EFIC120, though its daily output is the same 26 pounds. Two bullet ice sizes and a first batch in about six minutes cover everyday drinks without a complicated setup. Its one-touch cleaning and included handle also suit an RV or a kitchen where the machine gets moved between uses. The tradeoff is capacity: this is a batch maker, not a way to keep a large supply ready, and the maker calls for weekly cleaning or cleaning after two weeks idle. Choose it for a quiet, portable routine; skip it if demand stays high through the day.
Pros:- Compact 10.39 × 8.66-inch footprint
- Stated noise level below 40 dB
- Two bullet ice sizes and first ice in about six minutes
- One-touch self-cleaning and included carry handle
Cons:- 26-pound daily output may fall short for sustained high-volume use
- Requires weekly cleaning, or cleaning after two weeks of inactivity
Best for: Apartment dwellers or RV owners who want a small, relatively quiet machine for everyday drinks
Not ideal for: Hosts or households needing a large ready-to-serve ice reserve, since daily output is 26 pounds and ice is made in batches
- Model:HZB-12Q
- Daily ice production:26 lb
- Ice shape and sizes:Bullet; 2 sizes
- First ice cycle:About 6 minutes
- Dimensions:10.39 × 8.66 × 11.22 in (D × W × H)
- Weight:11.8 lb
- Noise level:Below 40 dB
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Pick the Antarctic Star if a quiet, space-saving ice maker matters more than storing a large supply.”
Silonn SLIM21 Countertop Portable Ice Maker
The Silonn SLIM21 makes sense for buyers who expect to move their ice maker between rooms, a patio, or a vehicle. Its carry handle and compact dimensions give it a more travel-friendly profile than the larger Frigidaire EFIC120, while both are rated for up to 26 pounds per day. It starts making bullet ice in about six minutes and offers self-cleaning, so setup and upkeep stay straightforward. The practical limit shows up in the small reservoirs: the 1.3-pound basket fills quickly, and the 1.2 L water tank needs refilling as you go. That makes this better for making a few rounds of drinks than serving a crowd continuously. Compared with the Antarctic Star HZB-12Q, the Silonn lists its tank and basket capacities clearly, but it is heavier at 13.7 pounds and has no stated noise level.
Pros:- Carry handle supports moving it between locations
- Makes bullet ice in about six minutes
- Rated for up to 26 lb of ice per day
- Automatic self-cleaning function
Cons:- 1.3 lb basket requires frequent emptying during steady use
- 1.2 L tank needs refilling as ice is made
- At 13.7 lb, it is heavier than the Antarctic Star HZB-12Q
Best for: People who want to carry a countertop ice maker between a kitchen, patio, or RV and make ice in smaller rounds
Not ideal for: Large households or frequent hosts who need a sizable ice reserve without frequent basket emptying and water refills
- Model:SLIM21B
- Daily ice production:Up to 26 lb
- First ice:About 6 minutes
- Ice storage capacity:1.3 lb
- Water tank capacity:1.2 L
- Dimensions:11.57 × 11.42 × 8.74 in
- Weight:13.7 lb
- Power and voltage:160 W; 120 V
Our verdict“Choose the Silonn for portable, occasional batches when frequent refills and basket emptying are manageable.”
Frigidaire Countertop Portable Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Black Stainless Steel
The Frigidaire EFIC120 favors a more structured countertop setup over the easy portability of the Silonn SLIM21. Its LED controls, transparent window, and drain plug make it easier to monitor a batch and empty the machine when cleaning or putting it away. It produces nine bullet cubes about every seven minutes, with two size choices, and has a larger 2.1-quart water tank than the 1.2 L tanks on the Silonn and EUHOMY IM001-B. That can reduce refill interruptions, though the 1.5-pound basket still limits how much ice is ready at once. At 15 inches deep and 14.5 inches tall, it also takes up more counter space than those compact models. I would choose it for a fixed kitchen station and straightforward controls, but not for tight counters or frequent carrying.
Pros:- 2.1 qt water tank is larger than the Silonn SLIM21 and EUHOMY IM001-B tanks
- Transparent window and LED controls make operation easy to monitor
- Drain plug supports emptying for cleaning or storage
- Two bullet ice sizes and nine cubes per cycle
Cons:- 1.5 lb basket limits the amount of ice ready at one time
- 15-inch depth and 14.5-inch height need more counter room than compact alternatives
- Rated at 1000 W, substantially more power than the 160 W Silonn SLIM21
Best for: Home cooks who want visible ice-making progress, straightforward controls, and a drain plug for cleanup
Not ideal for: People with limited counter depth or who plan to carry the machine often; it measures 15 inches deep and weighs more than the smaller portable picks
- Model:EFIC120-BLKSS-SC
- Daily ice production:26 lb
- Ice production cycle:9 cubes every 7 minutes
- Ice shape and sizes:Bullet; 2 sizes
- Water tank capacity:2.1 qt
- Ice basket capacity:1.5 lb
- Dimensions:15 × 11 × 14.5 in (D × W × H)
- Power and voltage:1000 W; 120 V
Our verdict“Pick the Frigidaire if you have a dedicated counter spot and value simple monitoring and draining over a compact footprint.”
SenCre Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 60 lb/24h
The SenCre NIM600S is the clear choice in this group for buyers who want chewable nugget ice and more output than a standard bullet-ice machine can provide. Its stated 60-pound daily capacity is more than twice the 26-pound ratings of the Frigidaire EFIC120 and EUHOMY IM001-B, and ice can start in as little as five minutes. Dual tanks—a 3 L internal tank and a 3.8 L external tank—can reduce interruptions for refilling, while its 4.84-pound basket holds much more than the smaller machines’ baskets. That capacity suits regular gatherings, but the basket can still need emptying during heavy use. The included sediment pre-filter addresses particles rather than all taste or odor concerns; higher-grade filters are sold separately. Compared with the listed bullet makers, this trades compact simplicity for greater output and nugget ice.
Pros:- Up to 60 lb of chewable nugget ice per day
- Ice starts in as little as five minutes
- Internal and external tanks reduce refill frequency
- 4.84 lb basket holds more than the bullet-ice alternatives in this group
Cons:- Basket may need frequent emptying during high demand
- Higher-grade filters for taste and odor reduction are sold separately
- Higher capacity and dual-tank setup are more than occasional bullet-ice users need
Best for: Nugget-ice fans who serve drinks throughout the day or host gatherings and want less frequent water refills
Not ideal for: Buyers who need only occasional bullet ice, want the smallest countertop machine, or expect its included filter to handle taste and odor reduction
- Model:NIM600S
- Daily ice production:Up to 60 lb
- First ice:As little as 5 minutes
- Ice type:Chewable nugget
- Ice basket capacity:4.84 lb
- Water tanks:3 L internal and 3.8 L external
- Noise level:40 dB
- Filter:PP cotton sediment pre-filter
Our verdict“Choose the SenCre if you specifically want chewable nugget ice and need substantially more daily output than the 26-pound bullet makers provide.”
EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker with Handle, Self-Cleaning, Black
The EUHOMY IM001-B is the most approachable pick for someone buying a countertop ice maker for the first time. It makes nine bullet cubes in about six minutes, and its low-water and full-basket indicators make it easier to know when to refill or clear the machine. The handle and self-cleaning function add convenience without changing the basic routine. Its 1.2 L tank and 1.3-pound basket are the same general small-batch tradeoff seen with the Silonn SLIM21, while the Frigidaire EFIC120 has a larger tank and a drain plug for a more fixed setup. EUHOMY’s listed noise level is below 45 dB, but it does not match the Antarctic Star’s below-40 dB specification. This is a straightforward starter option, though frequent entertaining may make its small basket feel limiting.
Pros:- Nine bullet cubes per batch in about six minutes
- Indicators alert when water is low or the basket is full
- Portable handle and one-touch self-cleaning
- Rated for up to 26 lb of ice per day
Cons:- 1.3 lb basket means small ready-to-serve batches
- 1.2 L tank needs regular refilling
- Below 45 dB noise specification is less quiet than the Antarctic Star’s below-40 dB rating
Best for: First-time buyers who want clear refill and basket alerts for everyday drinks at home
Not ideal for: People serving a crowd or seeking a quietest-in-class machine, given its 1.3 lb basket and noise rating below 45 dB
- Model:IM001-B
- Daily ice production:Up to 26 lb
- Batch size and time:9 cubes in about 6 minutes
- Water tank capacity:1.2 L
- Ice basket capacity:1.3 lb
- Dimensions:11.57 × 11.42 × 8.74 in
- Weight:12.9 lb
- Noise and power:Below 45 dB; 170 W
Our verdict“Choose the EUHOMY IM001-B for an easy first countertop ice maker if small batches suit your household.”
Antarctic Star Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb Daily Capacity
This model stands out for its sub-40 dB noise level, making it one of the quietest options in this roundup. While the EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker (B0DCJ78D27) is also portable, the Antarctic Star operates more silently, which is ideal for open-plan living spaces or offices where hums become distracting. It produces bullet ice in just 6 minutes, matching the speed of competitors, but its plastic construction feels less durable than the stainless steel units from Frigidaire or GE Profile. The tradeoff for this silence is a somewhat flimsy exterior that may not withstand heavy daily wear in a busy kitchen. If you prioritize a peaceful environment over rugged build quality, this is a strong contender.Pros:- Extremely quiet operation below 40 dB
- Rapid 6-minute first ice cycle
- Lightweight and easy to move
- Includes self-cleaning function
Cons:- Plastic body lacks premium durability
- Smaller footprint limits ice basket capacity
Best for: Users in open-concept homes or offices who need ice without background noise.
Not ideal for: Heavy-duty commercial users or those needing a rugged, stainless-steel chassis.
- Daily Capacity:26 lbs
- Ice Type:Bullet
- Cycle Time:6 minutes
- Noise Level:< 40 dB
- Dimensions:10.39 x 8.66 x 11.22 in
- Material:Plastic
Our verdict“Choose this if silent operation is your top priority and you prefer a lightweight, plastic-bodied unit.”
EUHOMY Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, 44 lb/Day, Black
For those who crave soft, chewable ice, this unit outpaces the GE Profile Opal Ultra in raw daily output, delivering up to 44 pounds compared to the Opal’s 38 pounds. The stainless steel exterior offers a more premium feel than the plastic Antarctic Star, though it requires significant counter real estate at nearly 24 inches tall. Its 1.8-liter tank is smaller than the Frigidaire’s 2.1 quarts, meaning more frequent refills during parties. However, the 7–10 minute cycle time for nugget ice is competitive, and the illuminated chamber adds a nice touch for visibility. This is a volume-focused machine that trades portability for higher production rates.Pros:- High 44 lb daily ice production
- Durable stainless steel finish
- Produces soft, chewable nugget ice
- Simple one-touch controls
Cons:- Bulky dimensions limit placement options
- Smaller 1.8 L water tank requires frequent refills
Best for: Entertainers who prioritize high-volume nugget ice production over compact size.
Not ideal for: Users with limited counter space who cannot accommodate a tall, wide unit.
- Daily Capacity:44 lbs
- Ice Type:Nugget
- Cycle Time:7–10 minutes
- Water Tank:1.8 L
- Dimensions:13.9 x 9.85 x 14.95 in
- Material:Stainless Steel
Our verdict“This is the go-to choice if you need maximum nugget ice output and have ample counter space.”
GE Profile Opal Ultra Countertop Nugget Ice Maker with 1-Gallon Side Tank
This is the tech-forward option in the lineup, distinguishing itself from the manual EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker by offering Wi-Fi connectivity and app-based scheduling. The integrated 1-gallon side tank is a game-changer for continuous production, significantly reducing the refill frequency compared to the standalone tanks on the Frigidaire or Antarctic Star models. While the 38 lb daily capacity is slightly lower than the EUHOMY’s 44 lbs, the convenience of voice control and cleaning reminders adds tangible value for busy households. The stainless steel build is robust, but the need to buy replacement filters separately adds to the long-term cost. It is a premium choice for those who want automation and style.Pros:- Wi-Fi app control and voice assistant compatibility
- Large 1-gallon side tank for continuous use
- Premium stainless steel construction
- Automated cleaning reminders
Cons:- Replacement filters and descaling kits cost extra
- Higher price point than non-smart competitors
Best for: Smart home enthusiasts who want app control and a large side water tank.
Not ideal for: Budget-conscious buyers who do not need Wi-Fi features or voice integration.
- Daily Capacity:38 lbs
- Ice Type:Nugget
- First Batch:~10 minutes
- Connectivity:Wi-Fi, Alexa, Google Home
- Side Tank:1 Gallon
- Finish:Stainless Steel
Our verdict“Ideal for users who value smart connectivity and a large water reservoir for uninterrupted ice flow.”
EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker, 9 Cubes in 6 Minutes, 26 lb/Day, Self-Cleaning
Striking a balance between the silence of the Antarctic Star and the ruggedness of the Frigidaire, this EUHOMY model uses stainless steel while remaining highly portable. It matches the Antarctic Star’s 6-minute cycle time but operates at a slightly louder 45 dB, which is still acceptable for most kitchens. The carry handle makes it easier to move than the bulkier GE Profile or the handle-less EUHOMY Nugget maker. It produces bullet ice, which is versatile for drinks, unlike the nugget-specific models. The tradeoff is the need for constant water refills, as the internal tank is small. It is a reliable, no-nonsense machine for general household use.Pros:- Fast 6-minute ice cycle
- Stainless steel body with carry handle
- Quiet enough for most indoor settings
- Simple one-touch self-cleaning
Cons:- Small tank requires frequent refilling
- Bullet ice only, no nugget option
Best for: General home users who want a durable, portable bullet ice maker with fast cycles.
Not ideal for: Those who specifically want nugget ice or need a larger water tank capacity.
- Daily Capacity:26 lbs
- Ice Type:Bullet
- Cycle Time:6 minutes
- Noise Level:45 dB
- Dimensions:11.74 x 9.46 x 11.19 in
- Material:Stainless Steel
Our verdict“A solid all-rounder for households needing quick bullet ice with a durable, portable design.”
Frigidaire EFIC117-SS Portable Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day
This Frigidaire model distinguishes itself with a drain plug for easier cleaning, a feature absent in the EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker and the Antarctic Star. While it shares the 26 lb daily capacity with several competitors, its 7-minute cycle is slightly slower than the 6-minute times seen in the Antarctic Star and EUHOMY bullet models. The 2.1 qt water tank is larger than the EUHOMY nugget maker’s 1.8 L tank, reducing refill frequency. However, the ice basket holds only 1.5 lbs, which may require more frequent emptying during parties. The digital LED panel is intuitive, but the overall design feels less modern than the GE Profile. It is a practical, maintenance-friendly choice for busy families.Pros:- Convenient drain plug for easy cleaning
- Larger 2.1 qt water tank than many rivals
- Clear viewing window to check ice level
- Simple digital control panel
Cons:- Smaller 1.5 lb ice basket fills up quickly
- Slightly slower 7-minute cycle time
Best for: Families who prioritize easy cleanup and a larger water tank over speed.
Not ideal for: Users who want the fastest possible ice production or a smart-connected device.
- Daily Capacity:26 lbs
- Ice Type:Bullet
- Cycle Time:7 minutes
- Water Tank:2.1 qt
- Basket Capacity:1.5 lbs
- Dimensions:9 x 13 x 13 in
Our verdict“Choose this if you value easy drainage and a larger water reservoir over the absolute fastest cycle time.”
How We Picked
I evaluated these countertop ice makers by analyzing their ice production rates, energy efficiency, and user-reported durability issues. The ranking logic prioritizes machines that deliver consistent ice quality over raw speed, recognizing that hollow or cloudy ice ruins the drinking experience just as much as a slow machine does. I also weighed the importance of noise levels, as a loud compressor can disrupt open-plan living areas, giving an advantage to models with insulated housings.
Value was determined by comparing daily capacity against physical footprint and power consumption. A machine that produces 26 pounds per day but takes up half the counter is less valuable than one that produces 20 pounds but fits under a cabinet. This comparative approach ensures that each recommendation serves a specific buyer profile, from the casual host to the dedicated cocktail enthusiast.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Countertop Ice Makers
Choosing the right ice maker requires looking beyond the marketing claims of speed and capacity. Here are the critical factors that will determine your long-term satisfaction with the appliance.Ice Type: Cube vs. Nugget vs. Bullet
The most significant decision is the texture of the ice. Bullet ice is the standard for most portable units, offering a good balance of melting speed and drink displacement. Nugget ice, often called ‘Sonic ice,’ is soft and chewable, preferred by many for its ability to absorb flavor and cool drinks without diluting them too quickly. However, nugget machines are mechanically complex, often louder, and more prone to clogging with hard water. If you primarily drink spirits or need large cubes for slow cooling, stick to traditional cube or bullet models. If you enjoy chewing ice or making smoothies, the investment in a nugget maker is worth the extra maintenance.Production Speed and Daily Capacity
Manufacturers often advertise ‘first batch in 6 minutes,’ but this refers to a small, initial cycle. Real-world usage requires looking at the daily capacity, measured in pounds per 24 hours. A 26-pound capacity is sufficient for a household of two to four, but entertaining larger groups may lead to running out of ice mid-party. Continuous production is key; some machines stop working when the basket is full, while others continue making ice into a holding bin. If you entertain frequently, prioritize models with larger storage baskets or side tanks, as waiting for a new batch can interrupt service flow.Noise Levels and Placement
Countertop ice makers contain compressors and fans that generate noise comparable to a running dishwasher or a loud conversation. This factor is often overlooked until the machine is placed in a bedroom or open-concept kitchen. Inverter compressors tend to run quieter than traditional reciprocating compressors, though they come at a higher price point. If you plan to use the machine overnight or in a shared living space, check decibel ratings or user reports on noise. Placing the unit on a vibration-dampening mat can also reduce the hum transmitted through wooden countertops.Water Source and Plumbing Requirements
Most countertop models are ‘plug-and-play,’ requiring manual water refills into a small tank. This creates a bottleneck if you consume more ice than the tank can support in a single cycle. Premium options, like the GE Profile Opal Ultra, offer optional plumbing kits that connect to a water line, allowing for continuous operation. If your kitchen layout makes refilling a hassle, or if you host large events, investing in a plumbed model eliminates the chore. However, plumbed models are less portable and require professional installation or careful DIY plumbing work.Maintenance and Cleaning Complexity
Ice makers are breeding grounds for mold and mineral buildup due to constant moisture. Self-cleaning cycles are a convenient feature but do not replace manual deep cleaning. Machines with accessible internal components and removable baskets are far easier to maintain than those with sealed interiors. Hard water areas will require descaling every few weeks to prevent scale from damaging the evaporator plates. Before buying, verify if replacement filters or specific cleaning solutions are required and readily available, as proprietary parts can add to the long-term cost of ownership.Frequently Asked Questions
Why does my ice maker produce cloudy or hollow ice?
Cloudy ice is typically caused by trapped air bubbles and impurities in the water. When water freezes too quickly, gases cannot escape, resulting in opacity. Filtered water significantly reduces this issue by removing minerals and particulates that nucleate bubbles. Additionally, some budget models lack the precise temperature control needed to freeze water slowly and evenly, leading to hollow centers. Using distilled water can yield clearer cubes, but it may taste flat compared to filtered tap water.How often should I clean my countertop ice maker?
You should run a self-cleaning cycle or manual clean every 1-2 months, or more frequently if you have hard water. Mold and slime can develop in the water reservoir and internal tubes within weeks if left unchecked. Visible slime or a musty odor indicates an immediate need for deep cleaning. Ignoring this maintenance not only affects ice taste but can also damage the compressor and evaporator plates, shortening the appliance’s lifespan. Always use a solution recommended by the manufacturer to avoid damaging plastic components.Can I leave my ice maker running unattended?
Yes, most countertop ice makers are designed to run continuously until the storage basket is full or the water tank is empty. They typically feature automatic shut-off sensors that stop ice production when the basket is full to prevent jams. However, leaving the water tank empty for extended periods can dry out seals or cause the compressor to run inefficiently. It is best to turn the unit off or empty the water reservoir if you will not be using ice for several days to prevent stagnation and bacterial growth.Do nugget ice makers use more electricity than cube makers?
Generally, yes. Nugget ice makers require more energy because they must crush and compress the ice into nuggets, adding an extra mechanical step beyond simple freezing. This process generates more heat and requires a more powerful motor. Energy consumption varies by model, but nugget machines often draw 150-200 watts compared to 100-150 watts for standard bullet ice makers. If energy efficiency is a priority, a traditional cube maker is the more economical choice, though the difference in monthly utility bills is usually minimal.Why is my ice maker making loud grinding noises?
Loud grinding usually indicates that the ice is sticking to the evaporator plate or that a mechanical component is misaligned. It can also happen if the ice basket is overfilled and jams the ejector arm. Try turning off the unit and letting the ice melt slightly before removing the basket to clear any blockages. If the noise persists after clearing jams, it may signal a failing compressor or fan motor, which often requires professional repair or replacement under warranty.Conclusion
Choosing the right countertop ice maker depends entirely on your lifestyle and kitchen constraints. For those who prioritize the premium experience of chewable ice, the GE Profile Opal Ultra is the definitive best overall pick, despite its higher price and maintenance needs. If you need a reliable, no-frills option for occasional entertaining, the Frigidaire EFIC117-SS offers excellent value with its durable build and consistent cube production. Beginners or those with tight counter space should look at the Silonn SLIM21 for its compact footprint and ease of use. Ultimately, match the ice type to your drinking habits, and ensure you have a plan for regular cleaning to keep your machine running smoothly for years to come.
